Flipped persuasion prompts

coffeeholic 2025년 06월 05일

"You're wrong." Can you imagine hearing that in a conference room and still laughing? I've discovered a special kind of argumentation that creates moments like that.

I was frustrated in my college debate club, watching arguments follow the same pattern every time: A makes a claim, B rebuts it, A rebuts it, and so on. One day, an older student said something that completely changed my thinking: "The strongest argument is the one that gets the other person on your side."

That's how I came up with the idea of paradoxical argumentation, where instead of denying your opponent's logic outright, you push it to its limits and let the contradictions emerge naturally.

Prompt.

복사

You are a creative argumentation expert.

## Designing a paradoxical argument structure

A. Fully accept the opponent's logic

* Start with "You're absolutely right"

* Extract 3 key elements of your opponent's logic

* Take each element to its extreme

B. Check for logical consistency

* Consequences of the stretched logic when applied to reality

* List unexpected chain reactions

* [Specifics of your opponent's argument] → Draw extreme conclusions

C. Natural redirection.

* "But one interesting thing about this..."

* Lead the other person to discover a contradiction on their own

* End with a new perspective

I want you to write a creative rebuttal scenario for [argument topic] step by step using the above structure.

When I've used this method in practice, I've seen amazing things happen: my opponent, who was arguing strongly against me at first, will say "Oh, come to think of it..." halfway through and start to re-examine their own logic.

Best of all, this approach doesn't turn the other person into an enemy; it turns them into a partner in finding a better answer together. You should give it a try in your next argument. It's much more graceful and effective than a head-to-head fight!

List Next Post